Assisted Living
Memory Care
Independent Living
Home Care
Sign in

Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices

Get personalized guidance

For pricing & availability

Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices is a partner with A Place for Mom. Learn about Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices, and browse Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices reviews to find top-rated providers in your area.

7.7

Review Score

94 reviews
9 communities
Starting from $X,XXX/mo

Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices community listings

Showing 9 communities
Sort by
Filter by
Awards
best-meals-and-dining
best-meals-and-dining
Review Score
Care Type
See communities with

Otterbein Lebanon SeniorLife Community

585 N State Route 741, Lebanon, OH 45036

Starting at$X,XXX+ monthly
Photo of Otterbein Lebanon SeniorLife Community
7
7 Photos available
9.2
Review Score
44 reviews

Every staff member we have encountered seems genuinely happy to work there. We have spoken to many residents who have nothing but good things to say about otterbein. [name removed] is very happy in her...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living

Otterbein Lebanon is located on 1200 acres between Dayton and Cincinnati on SR 741. Enjoy historic downtown Lebanon, famous for its Golden Lamb restaurant and antique shops. Theatre, shopping, sporting events, parks and more are all conveniently located within a 30-minute drive. Otterbein...

... Read more

Otterbein Pemberville SeniorLife Community

20311 Pemberville Rd, Pemberville, OH 43450

Starting at$X,XXX+ monthly
6
6 Photos available
1
1 Floor plans available
7.9
Review Score
16 reviews

The first thing is OT/PT promptly did my assessment and it started right away. They come in daily and worked with me for 40 minutes or more. While sometimes the aides take awhile to respond to call light...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living

Otterbein Portage Valley is located nearby the city of Toledo and offers seniors the best assisted living experience and has so much more to offer its residents. It is also home to the Mud Hens baseball team and a zoo. Otterbein Portage Valley community for assisted living affords one the...

... Read more

Otterbein Franklin SeniorLife Community

1070 W Jefferson St, Franklin, IN 46131

Starting at$X,XXX+ monthly
10
10 Photos available
3.0
Review Score
4 reviews

We chose Otterbein because of the cleanliness, friendliness of the staff members, and she was familiar with the location since we grew up on Jefferson Street. The facility itself did not look like an...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living

Otterbein Cridersville SeniorLife Community

100 Red Oak Drive, Cridersville, OH 45806

22
22 Photos available
9.2
Review Score
11 reviews

Dad really liked that Otterbein was in an area where he could sit on the porch and enjoy the outdoors. The staff would call me if something happened or to touch base about his needs. He wasn't a fan of some...

Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living

The Otterbein Cridersville campus opened in 1988, and is conveniently located off I-75 in northwest Ohio. It blends the energy of urban life with the beauty of a rural retreat. When you visit this beautiful, 120-acre CCRC, you’ll see tidy homes sitting on friendly, little streets with generous...

... Read more

Otterbein St Marys SeniorLife Community

11230 State Route 364, Saint Marys, OH 45885

14
14 Photos available
9.0
Review Score
5 reviews

For our family this is the best thing mom still has her freedom but if she needs help it is there she has her own apartment but can have services when she's needs help. Yes I would recommend this facility...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living

Otterbein St Marys SeniorLife Community enjoys a rich heritage and has been dedicated to providing quality services since 1912.As a not-for-profit organization, Otterbein has earned a solid reputation as a trusted and valuable resource in the community. Some of the greatest assets are the people...

... Read more

Otterbein Marblehead SeniorLife Community

9400 North Shore Blvd, Lakeside Marblehead, OH 43440

12
12 Photos available
3
3 Floor plans available
8.0
Review Score
7 reviews

My mom moved into Otterbein Marblehead assisted living about two months ago, after a stint in rehab following a fall that broke her shoulder. She had previously been in Portland Place in Sandusky which was...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care, Independent Living

Located in idyllic Lakeside Marblehead, Ottawa County, Ohio, Otterbein Marblehead SeniorLife Community is a beautiful assisted living community committed to offering residents peace and relaxation.Our communities consist of both homes and apartments and are highly rated. Residents have access to...

... Read more

Otterbein North Olmsted SeniorLife Community

30344 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, OH 44070

4
4 Photos available

We chose Emerald Green because they are very clean. The Staff knew the residents by name. The staff went over and above to accommodate our care needs. The food was good. They could use more servers. We were...

Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living

Located in the upscale, welcoming community of North Olmsted, Ohio, Emerald Village Retirement Community is an assisted living community that provides a wide range of benefits. Located minutes from the mall, hundreds of restaurants, and the MetroParks, our community is the ideal place to call...

... Read more

Otterbein Sunset Village

9640 Sylvania-Metamora Road, Sylvania, OH 43560

My mother was in Sunset Village almost 2 years in the Overmyer Wing. When my mother first arrived one of the staff said your mother is our mother. It is the most loving and caring place I have ever seen. The...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care

Otterbein Tipp City SeniorLife Community

4385 S County Road 25A, Tipp City, OH 45371

Provides: Independent Living

Our free advisors can help

Please enter a valid name.

Please enter a valid email address.

Please enter a valid 10-digit phone number.

By sharing your contact information, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You also consent to receive texts and calls from us and our community customers, including telemarketing and/or advertising, even if your number is on a Do Not Call list. Outreach may be during quiet hours under all applicable laws, auto-dialed, or may use pre-recorded or artificial voice. Your consent is not a condition to using our service. Msg and Data Rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Text HELP for Help. Text STOP for Stop.

Viewing 1-9 out of 9 communities

Reviews
for Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices

7.7
Review Score
94 reviews

Review Score

94 reviews
7.7

Out of 10


5 star

62%

4 star

21%

3 star

10%

2 star

3%

1 star

7%

A Place for Mom has scored Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices with 7.7 out of 10 using our proprietary review score based on 25 reviews in the last 2 years. Over all time, Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices has 94 reviews with an average "overall experience" of 4.2 out of 5.

Overall Experience
58
19
9
2
6
Date Submitted
6
11
25
Reviewer
14
56
24
0
Care Received
28
21
41
4
81-94 of 94 reviews
Sort by

3.0
Anonymous - Family/Friend
Assisted Living
February 9, 2023
Verified Review
Otterbein Review

The food is great and the servers try very hard to please everyone as does the kitchen staff. The grounds and hallways are always well-kept and welcoming. The staff is friendly. This is the only facility that we looked at that would take Medicaid Waiver. The bathrooms are way too small to bathe in for elderly residents. The caregivers can never be found quickly. Very few of them seem to exist. The laundry staff is awesome! You couldn't ask for a place that has more activity areas and each is outstanding. Pricing is good as long as you don't expect caregivers checking in daily.

Cleanliness

5

Friendliness

5

Meals & Dining

5

Care Services

3

Activities

5

Staff

5

Value for Cost

4


3.0
Anonymous - Toured community
Memory Care
June 14, 2019

Beautiful facility and location is nice if you want to stay in Ohio...... we don’t think we will because of the weather.

Cleanliness

3

Friendliness

3

Value for Cost

3


3.0
Anonymous - Toured community
Memory Care
April 23, 2018

No one was there. We drove around the community and we liked the outside of the patio homes and ranches, but do not have any additional information. The inside of the area where the nursing/assisted living had odors. A few staff around that were friendly enough; we saw very few residents.

Cleanliness

3

Friendliness

3

Value for Cost

3


3.0
Anonymous - Toured community
Memory Care
August 7, 2017

Took a while for someone to return my call. They have no 1 bedroom apartments for Assisted Living, they are all studio style.

Cleanliness

3

Friendliness

3

Value for Cost

3


3.0
Anonymous - Family/Friend
Memory Care
April 1, 2015
Verified Review
I have some concerns

I'm okay with them. They aren't as responsive or as attentive to details as I would like. I feel like they are depending on outside help a bit much. When I toured, I felt very good and comfortable, my confidence level has dropped since we moved in. It's clean enough, there are no odors or anything. They don't keep my loved one as active I would like, though. The food is good, no issues there. The staff and everyone are very nice, and they are very apologetic when there is a mistake. I do have some concerns though.

Cleanliness

4

Friendliness

4

Care Services

3

Activities

3

Value for Cost

3


2.5
Anonymous - Toured community
Memory Care
September 20, 2017
Verified Review
Staff Seemed Disinterested In My Business

I toured a few different communities and this one did not make a very good impression on me. The women who gave me the tour left me with the impression she didn't care for her job. I didn't get the feeling that I was welcomed. There was never any followup from the sales department to see if I had made a decision or if they could help answer any additional questions I had. I did not like the fact that any additional care or services were an additional price on top of the room rate.

Cleanliness

2.5

Friendliness

2.5

Value for Cost

2.5


2.0
Anonymous - Resident/client
Assisted Living
September 19, 2025
Verified Review
Yours Truly Disappointed!

my discontent with the price and my services is a is an issue right now because the different departments do not communicate with each other at times when an event is canceled we do not get notification of the cancellation and you can tell by the schedule that department do not communicate with each other because there is overlaps in the schedule. The food is not good. Example: this evening we were presented with dry spaghetti, bare meatballs and non toasted garlic bread. Alongside was a spoonful of green beans.Also one canned apricot cut in half. The facility has only one nurse on duty from 12 midnight to 8am. She is basically responsible for all the meds that are scheduled during that time period, including the independent residents!

Cleanliness

3

Friendliness

3

Meals & Dining

1

Care Services

1

Activities

2

Staff

2

Value for Cost

1


2.0
Diana - Family/Friend
Assisted Living
November 3, 2023
Poor service in assisted living

My mother has dementia and is in Assisted living at Otterbein Lebanon. It is a beautiful place but the care is lacking. We have continually found that her room is very dirty, laundry not done, sheets not changed on her bed for weeks, food trays and trash pile up and are not taken out of her room When we try to find someone to help we usually find aids sitting around on their phones and we don't get anywhere! We are supposed to be called when a doctor sees her or orders a new prescription and this does not happen and we find out by accident. The lobbies are beautiful but the individual rooms are lacking.

Cleanliness

2

Friendliness

2

Meals & Dining

4

Care Services

1

Activities

2

Staff

1

Value for Cost

2


1.0
Anonymous - Family/Friend
Independent Living
July 24, 2025
Verified Review
Otterbein elderly families beware

We had chosen otterbein at first and well they are hands down the worst place I would take my parent as they made promises and then did a bait and switch with my mom


1.0
Beverly C - Family/Friend
Assisted Living
February 26, 2021
Do not take your loved one here

My mom was taken in for rehab. She went in walking but falling and came out in a wheel chair. The two showers a week were done on day 8 and day 15 at 9:30 pm. Her therapy was very inconsistent and doctor’s orders were not implemented. The long wait for help to go to the bathroom has now put her in depends. Shortage of staff does not excuse her lack of care.

Cleanliness

No data collected

Friendliness

No data collected

Meals & Dining

3

Care Services

1

Activities

No data collected

Staff

No data collected

Value for Cost

1


1.0
Anonymous - Family/Friend
Memory Care
August 5, 2020

My mother was in nursing for a month. Not enough help. Was not pleased at all with her care. For a retirement facility of this stature, nursing was the worst. Brought her home. Would rather pay for good care instead of payout money for awful care.

Cleanliness

1

Friendliness

1

Care Services

1

Activities

1

Value for Cost

1


1.0
Anonymous - Family/Friend
Memory Care
August 26, 2015
Bed bugs

BED BUGS........ the staff confirmed it was our room, but didn't come treat it for three days... They will let you go with sponge bathes for weeks. Hygiene is not a priority here.

Cleanliness

2

Friendliness

4

Care Services

1

Activities

3

Value for Cost

2


1.0
Anonymous - Toured community
Assisted Living
April 2, 2015
Verified Review
Would NOT recommend

We visited this community while looking into care options for a loved one, and it was an absolutely awful experience, I would not recommend them to anyone based on how we were treated. The administrative staff were unfriendly and unprofessional.

Cleanliness

1

Friendliness

1

Value for Cost

1


0.5
Anonymous - Family/Friend
Memory Care
April 9, 2017
Sorry Aid

There is a aid on nights on Newcomers Hall that is very round and heavy ([Removed]) is her name I think, She talks to the residents like [Removed], I was in there friday night 4-07-17 and she was screaming at a resident awful. She has been reported a number of times and they just don't care. Half of the time my mother n law never had an aid. You are better off putting your family some where else.

Cleanliness

0.5

Friendliness

0.5

Care Services

0.5

Activities

0.5

Value for Cost

0.5


Viewing 81-94 out of 94 reviews

Frequently asked questions

There are 9 total Otterbein Senior Lifestyle Choices Facilities.

More questions?

Ask an A Place for Mom local advisor at no cost.